Composite and amalgam fillings
A cavity is not something that lands on your tooth one bad day. It is slow damage that builds over months or years, and for most of that time it does not hurt at all.
Here is what a cavity is, how a tooth gets repaired, and the honest differences between a composite filling and a silver amalgam.
Tooth decay and how it progresses
Your mouth is full of bacteria, and that is normal. The problem starts when they sit on a tooth in a sticky film (plaque) and you feed them sugar. They ferment it and release acid, and that acid dissolves the tooth's hard mineral from the outside in.
Saliva fights back, especially with fluoride around, so a cavity forms only when the attack is more frequent than the repair. That is why how often you eat sugar matters more than how much at once: a soda sipped over two hours does more damage than one drunk in five minutes.
Enamel has no nerve endings, so you can lose a real amount of it and feel nothing. Pain starts only when decay reaches the layer underneath (dentin), which connects to the nerve. That silence is the problem: nothing warns you, and a cavity between two teeth is invisible from outside until an X-ray finds it.
Stages of tooth decay
Decay does not jump straight to a hole. Only the first stage can be undone.
- White spot — still reversible. A chalky opaque patch, usually at the gumline or around braces. The surface is intact; mineral has been drawn out from just underneath. No drill needed: with fluoride, careful cleaning of that spot and fewer acid attacks in the day, the tooth can pull mineral back in. It may stay visible as a mark, but it stops advancing.
- Decay in enamel. The surface has broken. Small, usually painless, and it cannot heal on its own because enamel has no living cells.
- Decay in dentin. Here most people finally feel something, usually a jolt with cold or sweets. Dentin is softer, so decay spreads faster and sideways: a small dark dot often hides a much bigger cavity.
- Decay into the nerve. Once bacteria reach the pulp, no filling will save the tooth. Typical signs: pain lingering after the cold is gone, pain that wakes you at night, throbbing, pain on biting. Now it is a root canal, or extraction.
What a filling can and cannot do
Worth being blunt: a filling does not cure the tooth. Nothing regrows enamel. It is a repair with three jobs: remove the infected tissue so decay stops, replace the shape that was lost so you can chew, and seal the tooth so bacteria cannot get back in.
That last one is underestimated. Most failed fillings do not fall out; they leak at the edge, and a new cavity grows under a filling that still looks fine. That is why the seal, not the hardness, gets checked at every visit.
Amalgam and composite compared
| Amalgam (silver) | Composite | |
|---|---|---|
| Made of | Silver, tin, copper, mercury | Resin with glass or ceramic filler |
| Color | Silver; darkens, casts a gray shadow | Your tooth shade |
| Tooth removed | More: it does not stick, so the cavity is cut with undercuts to hold it, healthy tooth included | Less: it bonds, so only the damaged part goes |
| Seal | None at first; corrosion fills the margin over time | Immediate if placed dry; technique-sensitive |
| Longevity | Very good, often many years in large back fillings | Good, but wears faster in heavy grinders |
| Sensitivity after | Metal conducts cold, so it can zing early on | Brief; depends on depth and bonding |
| Relative cost | Lower | Higher: more time, more technique |
On mercury content
Amalgam does contain mercury, bound into a solid alloy. Major health authorities, including the US FDA, consider it safe and effective for the general population, and there is no evidence-based reason to drill out sound, sealed amalgams in a healthy person.
The nuance is real. The FDA has noted some groups may reasonably prefer alternatives where there is a choice: pregnant or breastfeeding women, children under six, a known mercury allergy, impaired kidney function. Mercury is also an environmental pollutant, which is why international agreements are phasing amalgam down. Those are honest reasons, not the same as "amalgam is poisoning you".
Why do many offices no longer place it? Appearance, and the healthy tooth you must sacrifice to hold it in. Not fear.
Types of composite and their indications
"Composite" is not one material. What changes is the filler: more filler means more strength, smaller particles mean a better polish.
- Flowable. Runny, syringed in. Weak on its own, so never a whole chewing surface. It goes as a thin first layer in a deep cavity, in narrow grooves, or in small defects at the gumline.
- Microhybrid. The older workhorse. Strong under chewing, but the shine dulls sooner, so not the first pick for a visible front tooth.
- Nanohybrid. Today's default: microhybrid strength with a polish close to the best cosmetic materials. Works front and back.
- Bulk fill. The curing light reaches deeper, so it goes in thick layers instead of many thin ones. Useful in deep molar cavities and with children, where chair time matters. It polishes less well, so it is often covered with a thin layer of something nicer.
- Body and enamel shades (layering). For front teeth. A real tooth is not one flat color: the inside is opaque and saturated, the surface translucent. The dentist builds it the same way, body shade first, enamel shade over it, so it does not look like a flat white patch.
Filling, inlay or crown: how the choice is made
A direct restoration is built in your mouth in one visit: the material goes in soft, is shaped, and hardens in place. That is a normal filling. An indirect one is made outside the mouth: the tooth is prepared and scanned, the piece is milled in the lab, then bonded in. A partial one is an inlay or onlay; one covering the whole tooth is a crown. Indirect wins on big cavities, where composite must be built in layers against a shape that is barely left and every layer shrinks as it sets.
- A filling is fine when the walls of the tooth are still standing and the cavity is small to medium.
- An inlay or onlay is usually better when the cavity is wide, a cusp is undermined, or a big old filling keeps chipping.
- A crown is usually the answer when a cusp has fractured, little tooth is left above the gum, or after a root canal on a back tooth, since that molar is brittle.
The trade-off is real: indirect work costs more and removes more tooth, so nobody should be talked into a crown for a cavity a filling would handle. With the family dental lab on site, an inlay or crown can often fit into a single trip.
The procedure, step by step
- Anesthetic. Topical gel, then the injection. Shallow enamel-only fillings are sometimes done without it.
- Isolation. The tooth is kept dry, ideally with a rubber dam (a thin sheet that isolates it). Adhesive fails if it touches saliva or breath moisture, and a failed bond is why fillings leak a year later.
- Removing only the damaged part. Soft infected dentin comes out, sound tooth stays, and work stays conservative near the nerve.
- Adhesive. The surface is conditioned, then a bonding agent is applied and cured. Everything else depends on this step.
- Layers. The composite goes in and is shaped in increments, rebuilding the grooves and the contact point so food does not pack between your teeth.
- Light curing. A blue light sets each layer in seconds. You may feel warmth, not pain.
- Bite adjustment. You bite on colored paper and high spots come off. A filling left slightly high hurts to bite on for weeks.
- Polishing. A rough filling collects plaque and stains much faster, so this is part of how long the work lasts.
Post-operative sensitivity
Mild sensitivity for a few days, sometimes a couple of weeks, is common after a deep filling: the nerve was irritated and needs time to settle. Cold and pressure are the usual triggers, and it should improve each day. Come back if:
- It hurts to bite on that tooth. Usually the filling is a hair too high and the adjustment takes two minutes.
- The pain lingers 30 seconds or more after the cold is gone.
- It wakes you at night, or throbs on its own.
- Heat hurts, or cold water relieves it: that points at an inflamed nerve.
- It gets worse instead of better after the first week, or floss shreds on that tooth.
One honest warning: on a very deep cavity the nerve is sometimes already too damaged to recover, and the tooth needs a root canal weeks or months after a filling that was done correctly. You should be told that beforehand.
Lifespan, wear and discolouration
It varies enormously, and anyone quoting an exact number is guessing. A small composite in someone who cleans well and does not grind can last many years; the same material in a heavy grinder can fail in a fraction of that. What shortens its life:
- Grinding and clenching (bruxism). The biggest factor on back teeth. A night guard protects the work more than any upgrade in material would.
- Poor cleaning, especially not flossing, and constant sugar. New decay at the margin is the most common reason a filling gets replaced.
- Biting ice, hard candy or popcorn kernels. Composite is strong, not indestructible.
- Not coming back. A leaking margin caught early is a small repair; two years later it is a crown or a root canal.
Staining
Composite picks up pigment from coffee, tea, red wine, dark sodas and tobacco. Surface stain settles into microscopic roughness, which is why a well-polished filling stains far more slowly. The resin also darkens and yellows internally over the years, and that cannot be polished out.
Repolishing often restores a lot of shine and is worth trying first. For internal darkening or a visible margin line on a front tooth, the composite has to be redone, and each replacement takes a little more tooth. Bleach does not lighten composite, only the tooth around it: whiten first, then match new fillings to the new shade.
Warranty and follow-up
Composite fillings here carry a two-week warranty against the filling coming out or fracturing. Beyond that the work is guaranteed, not the biology: no one can promise a tooth will never decay again. Restorations are checked at least once a year to verify the seal and confirm no new decay is starting underneath.
Frequently asked questions
Should I have my old silver fillings taken out?
Not just because they are silver. If an amalgam is intact, sealed and the tooth around it is healthy, leave it and watch it: drilling out a good filling always costs you tooth. Real reasons to replace one are a cracked filling, decay at the margin, a fractured cusp, or a gray shadow that bothers you when you smile.
Can a white spot really be reversed without drilling?
Yes, if the surface has not broken yet. With fluoride, careful cleaning and fewer acid attacks through the day, the tooth can pull mineral back in. It takes months, not days, and the spot may stay visible as a mark. Once the surface has collapsed, no product will rebuild it.
Can I eat right after a filling?
Composite is fully hardened by the light before you leave, so the material needs no waiting. The real limit is the anesthetic: while numb you can bite your cheek, lip or tongue without feeling it. Wait until sensation is back, usually two to four hours. Amalgam is not fully set right away, so avoid chewing hard on it for 24 hours.
What does the price depend on, and does my PPO insurance cover it?
Nothing is quoted before an exam, because it depends on which tooth it is, how many surfaces are involved, how deep the decay goes, and whether a filling is still appropriate or the tooth needs an inlay or a crown. An X-ray is usually needed to know.
This office accepts US PPO insurance: you pay here and your insurer reimburses you by check to your US address, usually in about a month. Claims carry the tooth in both FDI and universal numbering.
They found several cavities. Do I have to do them all at once?
No. A treatment plan is a suggestion, not a debt: you only owe what has actually been done. What matters is the order. Anything close to the nerve, hurting, or at risk of fracturing goes first; small shallow lesions can be spread over several visits. What does not work is stopping halfway and disappearing.
This guide is general information written by the practice. It is not a diagnosis: what is right for your mouth can only be decided after an examination and X-rays.
Related topics
Crowns & bridges
When a tooth needs a crown instead of a filling, how inlays and onlays differ, which material to pick, and how long crowns really last.
Read the guideRoot canals
How a root canal works, why a treated tooth fails later, what retreatment involves, and when a tooth can no longer be saved.
Read the guidePrevention & X-rays
How often to come in, how to brush and floss so it actually works, what sugar frequency does to teeth, and what each dental X-ray shows.
Read the guideSchedule your appointment with Dra. Itzel Gallegos
Send a WhatsApp message with your question, or a photo of the tooth that is bothering you. The answer comes from the practice, not a call center.